A Runner's Daughter

Tobacco and Indian oppression! That's what Virginia does!

Name:
Location: Civil War Mecca, Virginia

Sunday, February 05, 2006

Hemingway Thoughts

I finished A Farewell to Arms this week. What started out as slow going turned into a fascinating book. This was my first Hemingway; I am well-acquainted with Fitzgerald, so I thought I would stay in the same time period and read something from his equally famous contemporary. At first, I struggled through it because Hemingway is famous for his short, declarative sentences, which at first made me feel like I was reading on a sixth grade level. His main characters, Henry and Catherine didn't really say or feel too much. It seemed to mostly consist of:

"Do you love me?"
"Yes, you are a grand woman."
"I knew you would say that."

This goes on and on (amongst the war and Henry getting severely wounded) and suddening lo and behold Catherine is pregnant. You had to pay pretty close attention to catch the actual sex in the story. Hemingway would describe it with one sentence and move on. If you weren't careful you would miss it. So suddenly Catherine is carrying Henry's child and he has to go back to the Italian front. He sees fighting, participates in the murder of his own officer and then runs away from the whole thing back to Catherine. At this point in the book, I'm practically screaming at the characters to FEEL something. Hemingway keeps writing in the short declarative sentences and the murder of the officer was treated in about half a page. And then was never mentioned again. I was going nuts because Henry was experiencing so much that I just wanted him to cry or get angry or display some outpouring of emotion, but he never did. The same thing with Catherine. She helped Henry escape, she was pregnant and unmarried and going through so much turmoil but she herself never had any sort of display of any type of emotion. And this was effectively, perplexing me. I won't give away the ending of the novel, but suffice it to say, Henry concludes with just walking away from another emotionally charged moment without feeling or saying anything. But it was at the end of the novel when it dawned on me that that was Hemingway's point! He was trying to get across to the reader that prior to the story Henry and Catherine had felt so much, seen so much (Catherine had an ex-fiancee who was blown to bits by shelling) that they couldn't feel anything. The war, devoid of meaning and purpose, had drained them both emotionally and they were just two characters walking around, exisiting, but not truly living. The war had sucked the life out of both of them and that was the point of the novel: to parallel what the war was: devoid of meaning and purpose.

I had a very scholarly moment when I figured that whole thing out.

So yes, you must get through the way Hemingway writes and understand that he's using his language to help create a world that we are definitely unfamiliar with. A world where it's normal to have no emotion. So I do recommend the book and I'm not going to give away the ending. It's very good, definitely worth your time if you're interested. I will say though, that I still prefer Fitzgerald, he's much more of a sarcastic writer which I enjoy. But I definitely found a new respect for Hemingway.

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home